« MNLA Tuaregs Take Kidal - TTG | Main | "Legio Patria Nostra" »

30 January 2013

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Ben

Sounds like the email writers were making a necessary point -- 99% of the citizens of the republic have no family members in the armed forces and didn't seem to care much about the strain on members of the Armed Forces and their families during the Neo-Conservative adventures of The Decider President.

David Habakkuk

kao_hsien_chih

I think it has to be just a story. The film, obviously, had to simplify. Howard commanded the coup de main force, whose task was to achieve total surprise and capture both the bridge over the Caen Canal, and the adjacent bridge over the Orne, intact if possible: which they did.

The much larger 7 Para force, which obviously could not achieve surprise, was dropped shortly after, and the defence of the bridges was commanded by their CO, Lieutenant-Colonel Richard Geoffrey Pine-Coffin, one of whose subordinates Todd was.

The notion of having an actor playing Todd reporting to Todd playing Howard was probably a joke.

As I noted, Howard was a pre-war regular army NCO promoted officer. Pine-Coffin was a pre-war regular officer, coming from an old Devon family with a strong military tradition, educated at Eton and Cambridge.

Some years before, Todd had played Guy Gibson, who led the famous 'Dambusters' raid, in a film which was indelibly impressed on the minds of many schoolboys of my generation. So he was an obvious choice for the role created by conflating Howard and Pine-Coffin.

harry

Absolutely - Northumberland is much like Maine, although I have to say I am always reminded of Western Scotland when I got to Maine. There are hills in Northumberland but no mountains. Lincolnshire is a tough place as well. Climate is not as cold but its very very flat and right on the sea. The sky seems very low there and is generally grey. I think you have to be tough minded to live there.

I think you would enjoy the UK. Dont let anyone kid you - most Brits love Americans. However its not a polite place. If you want polite I think the United States is better.

turcopolier

harry

I've spent a lot of time in London and Kent but that is about it. pl

BruceR

Not really analogous though, is it? The British in 1775 weren't after small arms at all, they were trying to corral up cannon and the large quantities of powder those cannon required, because those were the only real threat to their military control of Boston.

Since many if not most of those cannon had been previously "liberated" in raids of Crown forts like Fort William and Mary by John Sullivan and others, a closer analogy today would be if a local militia broke into a federal base and seized and drove off artillery or heavy armored vehicles, complete with ammunition, for potential future use in an uprising. What would the appropriate federal response be in that hypothetical? Lincoln seemed to have a pretty clear idea on that subject.

A lot of what we would consider appropriate behavior for citizens in a non-democracy like the Thirteen Colonies in response to oppression doesn't seem so honorable when those citizens have the vote.

turcopolier

BruceR

Nationalist drivel. You may worship lincoln but I do not. The 13 colonies all had legislatures and if they would have been willing to live with the "supervision" of the Westminster parliament they could have run their internal affairs pretty much as they pleased. They were not willing to do that. You are obviously a faithful Tory servant of current policty in Afghanistan, etc. Enjoy. Your side of the argument has brought the United States to stalemate and then to efeat in Iraq and soon in Afghanistan. The "surge" in Iraq was a flop. The Awakening had little to do with the Surge and that is what Hagel should have told the madman from Arizona. BTW, what is your present or past rank in the US armed forces and what is your experience? Try not to lie. I see that you are in Ottawa. Why did I not know? pl

Tyler

Universal Franchise. Functioning Republic.

Pick one.

Fred

That's rich! Seems the British forgot about all those cannon aboard privately owned sailing vessels. The dozen or so cannon captured by Sullivan sure didn't equip any privateers.

http://www.awiatsea.com/Privateers.html

The real threat to British control of Boston was a variety of Acts in Parliament and other offenses quite well enumerated in the Declaration of Independence.

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

November 2020

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30          
Blog powered by Typepad