« Israel "counseled" on Iran by US and UK | Main | Egyptian mob attacks US embassy in Cairo. US Ambassador apologizes for free speech in the USA. »

11 September 2012

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Jose

The bigger, IMHO, threat is Turkey becoming more Wahhabi in their outlook as a result of cooperation with Saudi Arabia.

Remember Pakistan cooperating with the Mujahedin in the 1980's and the multiple changes to the Pakistani ISI and Company-grade officers at the time.

Medicine Man

Interesting how the punditry flirts with the truth by acknowledging Turkey and SA's involvement with the insurgents in Syria but doesn't go so far as to spell out the implications. Their employment must depend on that shortsightedness.

mbrenner

I see little point in critiquing the substance of the editorial since all its asserted 'facts' are wrong; its premises unjustified; its logic non-existent; and it's dishonest in masquing the truth that it began with a conclusion dictated by its commitment to the Netanyahu view of the world. This is a crude political act - nothing more. It should be analyzed as such.

Medicine Man

Col.: Is there any substance to the Post's claim that the insurgency in Syria could destabilize SA and/or Turkey? While I think you're right to skewer the logical fallacies on display, I have wondered for some time if the Saudis might be playing with fire encouraging rebellion the way they are. Though ostensibly Whabbist, might not the rulers of Saudi Arabia be vulnerable to challenge from fundamentalists in their own country?

The beaver

Colonel

Erdogan has likened the violence in Syria to the battle of Karbala:
http://www.reuters.com/video/2012/09/07/turkey-pm-erdogan-compares-syria-violenc?videoId=237594830

Later on it was reported that he said that his remarks was misconstrued but this is not the first time that he has referenced Karbala ( last yr when NATO was urged to help the rebels in Libya)

turcopolier

MM

Only if their jihadi allies do not win and they can be accused of not supporting them enough. pl

John Adamson

This week's Bloomberg Business week has a lead article by Jeffrey Goldberg which is essentially neocon propaganda.

The article didn't amaze me, but the fact that Mr. Goldberg's status as an US-Israeli dual was not disclosed did surprise me.

Actually, I shouldn't have been surprised. The media are fundamentally dishonest when it comes to promoting Israel's interests. Maybe I'm naive, but I would expect better from Bloomberg.

Tony

"Only if their jihadi allies do not win and they can be accused of not supporting them enough."

What if Iran and Iraq fed up with SA and Turkey and decide to return the favor by instigating violence in those countries? just a thought!

Petrous

As always, this is another excellent post about the ME and the one sided optics used by some of our leading papers to look at the events there. Do the guys advocating the sacrifice of our sons and daughters in foreign wars ever pause and think for a moment about what they preach. Or because most of them have no stake in the volunteer army nary a thought is given to the lives at risk?

Why in the world would it matter to the stability of Saudi Arabia or Turkey if Bashar Assad stays? Is antagonizing Iran worth the spillage of our, or anybody else's blood? Saudi Arabian Procrustean gerontocrats would be better off thinking about their own internal weaknesses, and how their own demise might blossom by sowing the seeds of sectarian hatred all over the region. Turkey also seems to forget that the meddling in Syria could have consequences not only for its Kurdish population (the most oppressed of the region) but for the more than half a million Alawiis living in Turkey. Most all of whom are strong supporters of the Alawite president of Syria.

Babak Makkinejad

In fact, Ayatollah Khamenei, in a speech 2 weeks ago observed that other countries could experience a similar situation as Syria if arms are given to their protestors and malcontents.

At the time, I considered that to be a warning and a threat.

Ishmael Zechariah

Tony,

This is already happening in Turkey. Erdogan, who did his military service as a private manning the canteen of his unit, is learning that playing "Ataturk" is not that easy. Pity he did not learn this when he tried to ride.
http://okans.wordpress.com/2008/11/14/ata-nasil-binilir/

Ishmael Zechariah

Pirouz

lol, Colonel I think it's spelled "Deputy Dawg".

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

August 2020

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
            1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31          
Blog powered by Typepad