Some Updated Information on the Innocence of Muslims Affair

Adam L. Silverman, PhD*

The Innocence of Muslims affair (incident?  incidents?) has become a fast moving story that seems to get more fantastical the more that gets reported.  It is now pretty clear that Sam Bacile is not an Israeli, Israeli American, or even Jewish.  Bacile is, apparently, a pseudonym for a Nakoula Basselly Nakoula - who appears to be an Egyptian emigre and was involved in this project with a number of naturalized American Copts and native born American Evangelicals.  Members of the cast have clearly indicated that the film was supposed to be/originally about Coptic persecution and was overdubbed in both English and Arabic with the anti-Islamic dialogue that has led to some serious problems in Egypt, Libya, and Yemen including the death of four American foreign service personnel.  The thirteen minute clip, posted to You Tube in July, began to gather interest over the past several days due to its being promoted by both Quran burning advocate Terry Jones and Egyptian-American Copt Morris Sadek.  The fatal anti-American violence in Libya may have partially been the result of various media and extremist movement sources claiming that the video had been produced for the 9-11 remembrances and was being widely shown on American TV on that day. 

While the story will continue to undergo change over the next several days as more facts come to light, the real issues are how does the US adjust its strategies and policies in the Middle East in response to these activities.  It also demonstrates very clearly that no matter what America's official positions, messaging, and actions are they can all be overcome by events regardless of whether they are unofficial messaging being transmitted by Americans - official or otherwise or the activities of the actual actors on the ground in the Middle East.

*Adam L. Silverman, PhD is the Culture and Foreign Language Advisor at the US Army War College (USAWC).  The views expressed here are his own and do not necessarily reflect those of USAWC and/or the US Army.

Comments

[The beaver]

The Arabic version came to be only in September even though the English version was available for awhile.
Read up on the timeline and on the agenda of Morris Sadek
You can find how he promoted it on his Twitter account and Facebook account (I am not going to publish it here)

[turcopolier]

jr786

There are as many Islams as there are Muslims. You know that. To say they are "illiterate" because they do not share your ijma' is illiterate. pl

[turcopolier]

CK

"Information op seems possible if not plausible" Why is it not plausible? Is it because you do not have enough specifics as yet? That seems to be pedantry. pl

[r whitman]

Is there any connection with this story and the previous absurdity of a Texas used car dealer with the help of Mexican drug dealers trying to asassinate the Saudi ambassador to the US. There is a lot of fantasy fiction in both.

[jr 786]

No, I'm not illiterate. I also know there is a hadith connected to this. In any case, there is little to no religous ground to this latest sense of affrontedness experienced by my co-religionists. In this little corner of the Muslim world where I reside, there has been little to no concern about the wankings of Western filmmakers.

What I do perceive is how readily some people pounce on anything they can use to re-organized Muslim thinking past the previous limitations of race, ethnicity or nationalism. Regardless of relative religous fervor or observance, everybody finds this offensive, but far less, say, than the images of Muslim women having wine thrown at them by israeli settlers that routinely make the rounds during Ramadan.

There's a project at work here to unite the not so religous Muslims with the social and cultural concerns of the rigorously religous minority. I think people should pay attention to that.

[The beaver]

CK

Just look for Sadek Twitter account and his FB page in cache ( he pulled it on Wednesday) and you will have your answes.

[turcopolier]

jr786

As you know but many here still do not, there is no hierarchy in Islam, any Islam. You don't like the conception of Islam held by the jihadi and mob people but that is really meaningless because God does not talk to you every day and tell you what he really wants. your Islam is the product of consnsus among some group of Muslims with whom you agree. As for a hadith, there are countless hadiths variously interpreted. pl

[Charles I]

Clifford, hello, hope you & the Ducati are well. I have missed you here.

to repeat myself in response to all asking who, what state actor, why, my comment from the previous thread may be apropos.

You don't even need a state or an institutional actor anymore. There is no Christian Zionist Politburo; there are many streams of wealthy whacked out ingenious and personable nabobs at the heart of civil society busily constructing a Dominion of Christian Capitalism. All connected to and relating to various other foreign fellows and foes.

They are able to harness, wield and focus enormous amounts of secular, intellectual, economic, political moral and religious energies with sustained discipline over generations, with access to the latest media technology and sundry levers of power. Not a vote amongst them.

They are the substance of books like Clifford Kiracofe's Dark Crusade, Jeff Sharlett's The Family, another I've touted here written by the disaffected son of founder the L'Arche movement in Switzerland, as well of course many others dealing with Jewish and Muslim actors.

Countries are just their workspace, and it has very little to do with governance, politics and international relations as we conceive them.

Or it could be Chinese - who don't lecture on human rights - just flipping the Arabs at an opportune hinge of history.

Many hands far apart pulling together unbeknownst to the whiole.

[Charles I]

Tell us more

[Charles I]

So is what Sadek was promoting the allegedly original Coptic persecution story or the Innocence of Muslims overdub, this seems to be just the murkiest thing, take a whole firm of articling students to chart/timeline this one out.

Seeing as I'm still at the Vegetable Patch, I look forward to seeing what er, we, come up with.

[LeaNder]

yes, Augustin, I was waiting for the devil to enter your lines at some point. Can you give us your sources or is it all in the bible? Revelations? If so, who told you to read it that way?

[LeaNder]

Michael Collins Piper?

[Cliffiord Kiracofe]

pl, I intended to convey that it was plausible and was possible.

Chs1, Ducati is happy and just did 7000 miles (partly through Canada) on the BMW.

Beaver, ok, thanks.

[LeaNder]

trooper, you should follow all of Adam's links, they "always" are worthwhile to follow. I know, he does not make it easy, since he does not easily connect them to single words or phrases as is the internet standard.

This is the relevant one:
http://www.theatlanticwire.com/global/2012/09/egyptian-outrage-peddler-who-sent-anti-islam-youtube-clip-viral/56826/

[LeaNder]

Sorry, TWG, it made me so mad, I could have saved my breath. ;)

Who was it, that reported from the ground in Syria on this list, is he well?

I can't help, for whatever reason this reminds me of his comment that he did not feel too secure in the masses handling weapons without the necessary training.

[The beaver]

Charles

Google his name "Morris Sadek" - everything on the first page will tell about the person.

[Walrus]

If the reports of at least Two of the actors are correct, the producer and director of the film took pains to conceal its true content from its actors. That tells us that it's makers knew the destructive power of its payload.

That it was spoken in English tells us nothing in particular, just that it was made in America. it would be very interesting to find out who dubbed it into Arabic.

Payload delivery via English dialogue failed. So someone tried again and succeeded.

I would very much like to know if this film has been brought to the attention of any other imams whatever in other countries and by who.

My guess is that this is a project of the fringe dominionist crowd - the church persecuted nuts, they think they can spark Armageddon.

Since I live close by 200 million Indonesian Muslims, I would like to see the producers of this vile little package incarcerated for a very long time, or perhaps delivered, living, to Saudi Arabia.

[turcopolier]

walrus

Perhaps you could stake them out as bait for Tasmanian Devils. I saw "The Hunter "recently." pl

[turcopolier]

Walrus

Can the Indonesians swim? In re the Suez Canal, the law I mentioned is the Constantinople Convention. If they want to scuttle a oouple of ships in the canal, that would be creative. It looks to me as though BHO is going to win handily. This is astounding given the state of unemployment. Joe Scarborough called Romney a "flawed candidate." May Moroni heed these words. Houseman next time. pl

[Tyler]

So even though its Muslims losing their shit, its still the fault of those evil Christians?

How convienient. I remember after Pussy Riot defiled the sacrament of the holiest church in Russian Orthodoxy how the Russian Orthodox community across the world started blowing up embassies and..

Wait. That didn't happen. Huh.

[turcopolier]

tyler

"It don't matter. It don't mean nuthin'." Did you ever see Martin Blank's explanation to "Debbie" of his "moral flexiibity" in "Grosse Point Blank." I have tried to live by that gospel as well as that in "Hopscotch." Istaghfur b'illah. pl

[Babak Makkinejad]

The English version plainly is mocking the Prophet and Khadijah - you only need to be familiar with Muslim history of Prophet's life; there is no ambiguity there at all.

The English dubbing, as I stated before, is by a person who is native Hebrew speaker.

The Arabic is Egyptian.

[Tyler]

Sir,

No I have not. I remember that expression though from "Hamburger Hill" and have heard and used its sister saying "It is what it is" over and over again.

Reading up on Grosse Point Blank, I think I can understand where you are coming from though.

[turcopolier]

tylare

Watch the movie. pl

[Babak Makkinejad]

Look; you have to accpet people the way they are. And having done that, I do not find any utility in going around making enemies.