You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.
Another interesting show. Clearly time has passed. And now people are speculating on impact of defeat of insurgents by MQ. As you discuss PL impact on EU seems enormous but so far they also are a no show in Libya but for the forlorn SAS types that were greated by arrest. Very complicated but suspect this situation will be clarified shortly in one way or another. No real evidence of organization in MQ's opposition IMO! Not all insurgencies succeed obviously.
The really sad thing is that MQ's deliberately disorganized "forces" are only marginally better fit to fight. This would be SO easy, nothing like standing up to Sunni insurgents in Iraq or worse yet, the 141st NVA Regiment, my old playmates. pl
I was quite impressed with the 141st NVA Infantry Regiment and still am after all tis time. i fought against many regular NVA units and they were IMO the best. pl
I picked up a copy of "Hell in a Very Small Place" by Bernard Fall the other day. Just skimming it 'till I have a few days. But some interesting comments about the affect upon both those who were POWs in the North after the battle. I'll have to give it a thorough read. It seems we learned some of the wrong lessons too, though that's been discussed here before too.
Another interesting show. Clearly time has passed. And now people are speculating on impact of defeat of insurgents by MQ. As you discuss PL impact on EU seems enormous but so far they also are a no show in Libya but for the forlorn SAS types that were greated by arrest. Very complicated but suspect this situation will be clarified shortly in one way or another. No real evidence of organization in MQ's opposition IMO! Not all insurgencies succeed obviously.
Posted by: William R. Cumming | 08 March 2011 at 06:48 PM
WRC
The really sad thing is that MQ's deliberately disorganized "forces" are only marginally better fit to fight. This would be SO easy, nothing like standing up to Sunni insurgents in Iraq or worse yet, the 141st NVA Regiment, my old playmates. pl
Posted by: Patrick Lang | 08 March 2011 at 06:55 PM
Even given attrition I think the NVA 141st Regiment was given its record an outstanding unit.
Posted by: William R. Cumming | 09 March 2011 at 02:56 AM
WRC
I was quite impressed with the 141st NVA Infantry Regiment and still am after all tis time. i fought against many regular NVA units and they were IMO the best. pl
Posted by: Patrick Lang | 09 March 2011 at 08:22 AM
Our (US) Viet Nam vets are aging fast and wonder about the NVA?
Posted by: William R. Cumming | 09 March 2011 at 10:27 AM
I picked up a copy of "Hell in a Very Small Place" by Bernard Fall the other day. Just skimming it 'till I have a few days. But some interesting comments about the affect upon both those who were POWs in the North after the battle. I'll have to give it a thorough read. It seems we learned some of the wrong lessons too, though that's been discussed here before too.
Posted by: Fred | 09 March 2011 at 12:22 PM