« The pope and the bishops | Main | The Newshour. Where is it going? »

18 April 2008

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Montag

The not-so-hidden hand of Iran in all this reminds me of that old joke about a school bussing dispute. One side wanted to bus some inner city kids out to the suburban schools, while the other side wanted to bus some suburban kids into the inner city schools. Who won? The bus drivers!

snadh

Pat, so why didn't you like the movie? The book was better? The DDL performance not doing it for you? The colour saturation on the burning derrick sequence pallid? What? Read your site regularly; keep it going.

Walter Lang

snadh

"snadh?" Sounds like it might be one of the mre obscure peoples visted by Gulliver.

I thought the film was pretentious, and sophomoric. Yes. There are people like Daniel Fairview. I kept hoping smoeone would put him out of his misery before he did more harm. Some films are awful to watch. "Leaving Las Vegas" was another. By the time they were through.... Arghh! pl

JohnH

I agree with this analysis. Bush/Maliki have to get control of the ballot boxes soon, so they can manage the outcome of the elections and get a parliament that will obediently roll over and pass the oil law that Bush so desperately needs before he leaves office. Otherwise his legacy of getting control of the oil spiggot will have been just a mirage in the desert.

Binh

Sounds like Maliki launched his Basra operation to pre-empt a move by Petraeus against Sadr in the south:
http://www.antiwar.com/porter/?articleid=12709

jon

So, in BAsra the Mahdi's command and control is being displaced, certainly with a fond hope that they will go quietly. Meanwhile in Baghdad, the US is establishing a blast wall perimeter around Sadr City, for the protection of the inhabitants, no doubt. And there and in other places, 'rogue elements' are being selectively picked off.

None of these phenomena could possibly be linked, and I'm sure that the Muqtada is quietly pleased with these developments and has encouraged his lieutenants to take some vacation days.

No. eventually this will be answered. From this distance, it's seemed impressively stoic how many losses the Shia and Sadr have accepted with outward restraint. I'm sure it's only because they see greater harm in overreacting, or greater reward in biding their time and choosing the moments to act.

There is a rhythm to the Mahdi Army's actions, and it seems that at the end of each cycle they have increased their reach and power substantially. Perhaps its time for the pipelines to catch fire again.

Serving Patriot

COL,

Meanwhile, a ragin fight has been ongoing in Sadr City - with U.S. forces in the lead and taking many casualties - without nary a peep from the American media.

Who could know? I mean "bitterness" was (and remains) much more newsworthy.

Progress seems to be made in Sadr City fight. At least enough pushing of Sadrists and JAM away from the river to perhaps end the rain of mortars into the Green Zone. Now, its time to "Fallujah-ize" that portion of Sadr City - erect the 20ft high "separation" wall and pacify the neighborhoods within.

And we wonder why Sadr has the Iraqi people on his side?

SP

jamzo

first i lost interest in the sunday shows during the clinton-monica thing

i lost interest in the news hour some time after gwen eiffel showed up, bush vs gore in florida and the iraq war

i remember checking in on the news hour some time ago and judy woodruff was speaking and i turned the tv off

jamzo

and like hamas, sadr and his mahdi army are the largest aid agency in iraq

they fill needs not filled by the un, the iraqi government or the US

sometimes i get the impression we are following the advice of israeli advisors

Montag

The Israelis are trying to revive the idea of a Kirkuk-Haifa oil pipeline, which they think will only cost $400 million to build and run through Iraq, Jordan and Israel. They hint that it would be a swell way for the U.S. to thank them for their "support" on Iraq. It's projected to be 42" in diameter and about 600 miles long. How they think it will be possible to protect it is anyone's guess, but with such Pharaonic projects the prestige is in the building, not the actual use--if any.

jon

SP - I'll take your prescription as ironic, hopefully.

I just ran a little math to determine that Sadr City contains about a million more people than all of Gaza, with a density 25 times greater. And it's about four times as dense as Manhattan, also with about a million more people, and on half the area.

Pacifying Sadr City will be a much greater task than Fallujah was/is. Fallujah was only a quarter as dense, having 400-600,000 people in an area of about nine square miles, for a maximum population density of 67,000 people per square mile. Now somewhat reduced...

Sadr City is based on large blocks/districts with smaller roads dividing them. It will be easier to isolate and secure areas, but a daunting and immense task. And as other examples amply demonstrate, while an area might be conquered, it cannot be secured if the people will not be conquered.

Also, the Green Zone continues to be mortared daily, despite the push on Sadr City.

Montag

Serving Patriot,
Our soldiers have received orders that they are no longer to refer to the enemy as "JAM," but to echo the propaganda coming out of Washington. You've heard of the uncola? Well they're trying to turn Sadr's fighters into the unIraqis. It's a branding issue. Our soldiers are just rolling their eyes at that one.

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

February 2020

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
            1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Blog powered by Typepad