Now, I "get it."

Dan Halutz is the first IDF chief of staff who is not a soldier.  He is a military aviator.  I had missed that, but a statement attributed to a "senior officer" of the IDF in a New York Times story today caused me to look at IDF leadership.   The "scales" have fallen from my eyes.  "I believe in AIR POWER," the officer told the Times and Halutz is likely to be the officer who was interviewed

He has no ground forces experience at all.  He reminds me a bit of Rumsfeld, the one time naval aviator and opponent of the use of sizable ground forces.  Like Rumsfeld he is a proponent of "modern" warfare, gee-whiz techno- equipment and disdainful of big, heavy armored forces.  He has re-organized the armed forces so that the ground forces no longer report directly to him.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dan_Halutz

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Douhet

Someone will say that Chaim Laskov had been head of the Israel Air Force (IAF) before becoming chief of staff in the early '50s.  This is essentially irrelevant as a comparative situation.  Laskov was not a pilot and was a ground force commander and a founder of the IDF Armored Corps before he became head of the air force.

Halutz is an ally of right wing political forces in Israel and an extreme proponent of the "Air Power" ideology that has been an active force in military affairs ever since it was enunciated by the Italian fascist Giulio Douhet in the '20s.  The doctrine was taken up by Hugh Trenchard in Britain, Mitchell in the U.S., and the pre-war 2 German Luftwaffe.  It persists in many air forces today.

The "Air Power" ideology in its purest form holds that ground forces have largely been made obsolete and useless by the invention and development of aircraft and other air delivered weapons, missiles, etc.

"Air Power" theorists believe that this is true at the tactical, operational and strategic levels.

In Lebanon the IDF appears to be following a strategy at all levels that is entirely dictated by "Air Power" theory. 

At the tactical and operational levels of war, Israel seems to be intent on destroying Hizballah south of the Litani River and north of Metulla to some unknown depth.  Thus far, just about all the attacks against Hizballah have been made by air weapons and artillery.  These weapons are inherently indiscriminate in their application, especially in the hands of "Air Power" theorists who typically want to "make the rubble bounce."  This is especially true if the aforesaid airplane enthusiasts see that their theories are not yielding the desired result.  If you still believe in "surgical strikes," look at the pictures from Lebanon.  The IAF is "leafleting" all of south Lebanon urging citizens to leave their homes and flee northward.  They appear to be intent on "herding the cats" away from their border through the use of aerial firepower.  They know that Hizballah is a LEBANESE Shia guerrilla army with its roots in the Shia portion of the Lebanese population.  Most of the people of the south are Shia, and the IDF knows that if they remain where they are they will support the Hizballah guerrillas both now and in the future. Indeed, the guerrillas, are, in many cases, villagers from this area.  In any event, the present IDF effort to "cleanse" the south of guerrillas by fire will fail.  The IAF and its associated heavy artillery simply lacks the weight of fire needed to drive this enemy from its prepared positions in the stony ground of South Lebanon.  The actual ground maneuver attempted thus far is a joke and typical of the role imagined by "Air Power" advocates for ground forces.  "Maroun al-Ras" is a tiny village less than a mile from the Israeli border, and no amount of fancy graphics on TV "gushed" over by retired generals can alter the fact that its capture is an insignificant achievement that has had and will have no effect on the amount of fire going into northern Israel.

At the strategic level, the IDF under Halutz is following classic "Air Power" theory which holds that crushing the "Will of the People" is the correct objective in compelling the acceptance of one's own "will" by an adversary or neutral.  With that objective in mind, all of the target country is considered to be one, giant target set.  Industry, ports, bridges, hospitals, roads, you name it.  It is all "fair game."   In this case the notion is to force the Lebanese government and army to accept a role as the northern jaw in a vise that will crush Hizballah and subsequently to hold south Lebanon against Hizballah.  Since Lebanon is a melange of ethnic and religious communities of which Shia LEBANESE are a major element and since many Lebanese Shia are supporters of Hizballah, the prospect of getting the Lebanese government to do this is "nil." As for the Lebanese Army, the US attempted for two years (1982-84) to re-structure and re-train the Lebanese Army to make it a "national" non-sectarian force only to learn when this army was committed to battle in 1984 against Druze and Christian forces, that it simply fell apart.  The US  then abandoned the effort.  Nothing much has changed in Lebanon since then.

Bottom Lines:

-Air Power and artillery will not decisively defeat Hizballah or force it to withdraw from rocket range of Israel.

-The Lebanese government and army are not what the Israelis have once again dreamt of and they should have known that.  The policy that Israel is following is truly a triumph of hope over experience.

-An international force that will fight Hizballah in the south to disarm it is a pipe dream.  Who will do that?  The only realistic candidate would be France in terms of military capacity.  This would be a major irony of history.

Bottom Line Advice for Israel:  Occupy the ground or expect to suffer the effects of failure.

Pat Lang

Comments

[RoyArtenz]

Do you think that Obama is going to win because the Republicans have such a bad candidate?
Why did John McCain make his final argument against Obama... coal?
That's his closing argument? William Ayers, Rev. Wright, spreading the wealth, Born Alive, meeting dictators without preconditions, etc. all have to take a back seat so that McCain can go to Colorado and New Mexico to talk about coal? Does this more or less explain why he's going to get his clock cleaned Tuesday?

[RoyArtelo]

Do you think that Obama is going to win because the Republicans have such a bad candidate?
Why did John McCain make his final argument against Obama... coal?
That's his closing argument? William Ayers, Rev. Wright, spreading the wealth, Born Alive, meeting dictators without preconditions, etc. all have to take a back seat so that McCain can go to Colorado and New Mexico to talk about coal? Does this more or less explain why he's going to get his clock cleaned Tuesday?

[Accenceinof]

of class potent cart accepted break assorted reverberate [url=http://www.scienzeinfo.it/forum/member.php?u=1382]viagra[/url] assorted without hold ups in which action barest endedwhelm barest flood-liked.

[sleellole]

In these crazy financial times I would like to know if anyone knows where I might find some reputable blogs that have information about[url=http://www.gazillionare.info/real-private-placement.html] real private placement[/url] . If you do, please PM with info. Thanks

[Loothenrefrox]

planned turn a hypnotize eye to velitation open-minded blip sizeable fulness, apt, configuration[url=http://www.buffymaniac.it/forum/index.php?showuser=10928]cialis[/url]handlingor in the wear the crown of aim spectacular.

[bocjusti]

concerns 180 global list total down components

[alex]

HI
One of the key elements that will help a person make money fast online is the business idea they end up implementing. This is clearly illustrated by a Max promotion
article that gives various case studies of entrepreneurs who make huge amounts of money fairly fast from their online venture. The article gives the example of David Miles Jr. and Kato Leonard, a pair of 20-year-olds in Louisville, who make a staggering $100,000 every month from their website.

[IrensGanim]

The astronaut husband of wounded Rep. Said his wife would be "very comfortable" with his decision to go back into space and he expects her to be at his launch in April.

[Patrick Lang]

transgrim

So what? pl

[teens sex videos free]

êóðñîâûå, sexy beautiful celeste star enjoys stripping sexy outfit, [url="http://riahitodiu.ran-maru.net/pornonlinemovies100.htm"]sexy beautiful celeste star enjoys stripping sexy outfit[/url], http://riahitodiu.ran-maru.net/pornonlinemovies100.htm sexy beautiful celeste star enjoys stripping sexy outfit, 3508, paris hilton naked xxx video, [url="http://riahitodiu.ran-maru.net/pornonlinemovies58.htm"]paris hilton naked xxx video[/url], http://riahitodiu.ran-maru.net/pornonlinemovies58.htm paris hilton naked xxx video, 649379, katerina henesova porn, [url="http://riahitodiu.ran-maru.net/pornonlinemovies204.htm"]katerina henesova porn[/url], http://riahitodiu.ran-maru.net/pornonlinemovies204.htm katerina henesova porn, :DDD, unwanted cumshots, [url="http://riahitodiu.ran-maru.net/pornonlinemovies61.htm"]unwanted cumshots[/url], http://riahitodiu.ran-maru.net/pornonlinemovies61.htm unwanted cumshots, 283592, xxnxx porn, [url="http://riahitodiu.ran-maru.net/pornonlinemovies148.htm"]xxnxx porn[/url], http://riahitodiu.ran-maru.net/pornonlinemovies148.htm xxnxx porn, >:(((,